Home

Advertisement

Older | Newer

Sunscreen vs. Vitamin D : Controversy?

  • Jun. 20th, 2008 at 8:20 AM
Right now, I'm finding so much information that I can't figure out what to leave out and everything's getting too long!  But you'll love this one!

I happened across The Skin Cancer Foundation's website.  They have a stern warning that babies should always be kept out of the sun, and a section on common myths about sunscreen.  Their first myth is ...

"Wearing sunscreen can cause vitamin D deficiency." 

There's even a link to a page on this "controversy."  There, they say that some physicians believe that "the simple solution to the deficiency is 5-10 minutes of unprotected UV exposure ... two or three times a week."  They go on to state that most dermatologists and cancer groups "have argued strongly against this 'solution,' since all unprotected [sic] UV exposure contributes to cumulative skin damage[.]"

Sooooo, I called them.  And I mentioned the reports coming out in USA Today, the New York Times, the AJC, all over the place, that we're in a epidemic of vitamin D deficiency, specifically b/c we use too much sunscreen, and that even babies are being found deficient in huge numbers.  I asked if they were updating their website to reflect the latest recommendations: "Experts suggest at least 15 minutes of direct sun a day before slathering on sunscreen."

The guy answering the phone said, "We now recommend spending 10-15 minutes in the direct sun two or three times a week."

Great!  "So, will you be updating your website to reflect that immediately?"

"I'll put in a report that you requested that."

"Most people encounter your important organization through your website.  Shouldn't that be updated immediately?"

"I'll note that you requested that."

?  Why not do it now?  ?

I don't know, surely it has nothing to do with being funded by sunscreen manufacturers.

I did *not* used to be a skeptic.  I didn't!

Here are the screen caps:






8/13/08 Update.

AMDG

Comments

( 2 comments — Comment )
(Anonymous) wrote:
Jun. 20th, 2008 01:48 am (UTC)
on the edge of my seat
i'm wondering what you do. we have a mix of fair and tan in our house. they wear a shortsleeve rash guard- no sunblock and a hat. they still get rays bc i notice their color but it's not so intense- burning and blistering and such.
btw- i really really love your blog. i visit almost daily. no pressure to keep up...it's a guilty pleasure that i don't really have time for anyway...but always want to squeeze it in.
keep it up.
peace,
elizabeth
(Anonymous) wrote:
Jun. 24th, 2008 03:18 am (UTC)
Hurray, for once being lazy and not liking to slather my babies and children and myself up with sunscreen has worked out in my favor. I am very fair but rarely if ever put on sunscreen. Off to check my face products to see what they contain.
God Bless,
Christy
( 2 comments — Comment )

Purpose

A collection of news that tells the truth about the world, in a world that holds News as an article of Faith, but rarely gets even half the picture.
Michaelangelo maria lactans



There are many kinds of success in life worth having. It's exceedingly interesting and attractive to be ...a President, or a ranchman, or the colonel of a fighting regiment, or kill grizzly bears and lions. But... a household of children... certainly makes all other forms of success and achievement lose their importance by comparison.

Theodore Roosevelt


Babywearing Bloggers
Powered By Ringsurf




counter stats

Latest Month

November 2009
S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Page Summary

Powered by LiveJournal.com