Home

Advertisement

Older | Newer

Man Eating Lemons!!!

  • Jun. 12th, 2008 at 4:47 PM
Okay fine.  The quintessential example of bad reporting & bad science: contaminated lemons

The claim: Lemon wedges in restaurants are full of fecal bacteria from waitresses who have just left the loo, and if you've been using them, you're lucky to be alive.

The reality:
  1. All produce has bacteria outside and inside it (the original study mentions this), and all hands will pass on what they have.  
  2. "Fecal" bacteria (e. coli, referred to as "gram-negative" in the study) are everywhere, even inside us right now! & on our hands, and they don't hurt us unless our defenses are weakened (usually by poor diet) & the source is unnaturally high.  
  3. Avoiding lemons won't solve anything - the waitresses in the restaurant I worked in made salad with their bare, unwashed hands. 
Those were my first thoughts, confirmed by a bit of investigation, starting w/ the primary source.  This analysis by a biology doctoral student concurs.  We shouldn't have to do this kind of research to get the truth behind the studies - the journalist should.  Instead, we get hype, since hype gets ratings.

Germophobia is dangerous for many reasons.  We should also know that all produce has bacteria and yeasts that come from the air and are present before it is even picked.  That's what the traditional food storage method of lacto-fermentation counts on for its success.  Those bacteria are almost exclusively beneficial, and populate our gut to form the bulk of our immune system.  We even take them in capsules - "probiotics."  The beneficial bacteria are present on the lemons to make us healthier, and the pathogenic ones are not pathogenic in such small, naturally occurring, amounts.

If I were really concerned about restaurant lemons, I think I'd be sure to skip the sugar, get more D via the sun, and eat plenty of probiotics at home that week, too.  ;)

AMDG

Purpose

A collection of news that tells the truth about the world, in a world that holds News as an article of Faith, but rarely gets even half the picture.
Michaelangelo maria lactans



There are many kinds of success in life worth having. It's exceedingly interesting and attractive to be ...a President, or a ranchman, or the colonel of a fighting regiment, or kill grizzly bears and lions. But... a household of children... certainly makes all other forms of success and achievement lose their importance by comparison.

Theodore Roosevelt


Babywearing Bloggers
Powered By Ringsurf




counter stats

Latest Month

November 2009
S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     
Powered by LiveJournal.com